On my day off, I had the pleasure of sitting on twitter for hours on end, communicating with the "educated Black folks" that I follow (and some of whom follow me) about John Mayer's
Playboy interview.
I like John Mayer. I do. I like his music. I like his "say what's on my mind" style. John Mayer is a musician, not a politician. I like the truth. Sometimes it's ugly, sometimes it hurts. But I very much enjoy it.
So, when John Mayer spoke, without thinking about what he said (or how others might misconstrue it), he sounded like a sincere man freely expressing his thoughts on a magnitude of topics.
There was nothing in the interview that bothered me as a Black woman. I was more concerned about how his former loves Jessica Simpson and Jennifer Aniston would feel about being mentioned in the same space, but one could not read the entire article and not notice how much that man adored both women.
How many women would be upset if they were likened to "crack cocaine"? Sheeeyit, I wish that were me. And how upset can you be that a man says that a relationship didn't work out because he was "just 32" and wasn't ready to be anything more than that? That's pretty respectful.
So let's talk about what had much of Brown America in an uproar Wednesday morning.
On John Mayer's Hood Pass...
“What does it feel like now to have a hood pass?” And by the way, it’s sort of a contradiction in terms, because if you really had a hood pass, you could call it a nigger pass. Why are you pulling a punch and calling it a hood pass if you really have a hood pass? But I said, “I can’t really have a hood pass. I’ve never walked into a restaurant, asked for a table and been told, ‘We’re full.’"
If he meant what I think he meant, he was questioning the validity of a Black pass when he can't use the word nigger nor experience, wholly, the black experience (i.e. being told a restaurant is full when it is not.) Moments earlier, he explained the Black experience as...
"...making the most of your life, not taking a single moment for granted. Taking something that’s seen as a struggle and making it work for you, or you’ll die inside. Not to say that my struggle is like the collective struggle of black America. But maybe my struggle is similar to one black dude’s."
Now, perhaps it's a bit much to liken his experience to any one Black man. But, I could see where he was going given his definition. Particularly since he elaborates, at length, about how he was indeed making the most of his life and taking his struggle and turning it into something beautiful.
On not dating Black women (aka the David Duke cock)...
"I don’t think I open myself to it. My dick is sort of like a white supremacist. I’ve got a Benetton heart and a fuckin’ David Duke cock. I’m going to start dating separately from my dick."
First, why do we care? Do we know how many white men don't date us? Shouldn't we be more concerned with the brothers that we do want (that don't want us) then the others that we don't want that don't want us? Truly, I thought he was trying to link the distance between his "Benetton heart" and "David Duke" cock by stating that he would expand his bed to welcome the Black women that he has long since adored, but never entertained (he said it further down in the same article.) And after seeking clarity, I get why the parallel to David Duke, even if in jest, isn't funny.
I get the interview was racy. It was a man speaking with no filter, defending his character and life choices. Perhaps he was too honest, and we don't want nor need honesty. Perhaps he shouldn't have spoken of Jessica Simpson as a sex goddess because I'm certain she was far more than that. But seriously, we missed some salient points. And more so, we missed a genuine man sharing genuine feelings. He is an artist, not a politician. He said what he wanted to. Very little of what he said was disrespectful to a class of people (Blacks, women, etc.) I saw a man with a "chip on [his] shoulder" defending himself, explaining his decisions, opening his heart and head. Without a filter. He didn't use the word "nigger" with ill intent. He used it to make a point and to affirm us. Why are we so mad?
Why did he apologize when he didn't have ill will? Because he hurt people? The truth hurts and sometimes, we have to learn to swallow it. Or...do we prefer doctored up, jazzed up versions of things? If he said "the N word" would people have been ok? Why did he apologize when he spent the entire article talking about how regardless of what you say, it will be misconstrued and people will be unhappy. Didn't he say that he had relegated to making himself happy instead of making the world happy?
What I've learned from this...
There are many Brown folks, with many official letters after their names, whose reading comprehension is piss poor. And that's more disappointing than anything John Mayer said. You know why? Cause John Mayer will still make records and make money, and have risky thoughts (even if he doesn't share them) and many educated Brown folks still won't be able to understand what they're reading.
(Sigh.)